More steps or a faster pace? A 2022 analysis offers clues

Estimated reading time: 3:16 min.

This article is verified by 1 study/publication.

Your tracker shows a daily step total, but it may also encourage you to walk faster. Which number should you watch? A 2022 meta-analysis helps explain what step counts and walking pace can tell us, and why the 2 aren’t easy to separate.[1]

Too long; didn’t read (Summary)

  • A 2022 analysis of 15 cohorts linked more daily steps with lower mortality during follow-up.
  • Associations with walking pace after accounting for step totals depended on the pace measure used.
  • This was observational evidence, not proof that a particular step count or pace prolongs your life.

15 cohorts, not a prescribed walking programme

The researchers combined 15 prospective cohorts involving 47,471 adults. Participants wore step-counting devices for about 1 week, then were followed for deaths from any cause. There were 3,013 deaths over a median follow-up of 7.1 years.

Taking more daily steps was associated with lower mortality. The relationship gradually levelled off around 6,000–8,000 steps a day among adults aged 60 or older, and around 8,000–10,000 among those younger than 60. These are ranges from statistical models of groups, not precise personal targets or a daily minimum below which movement is worthless.

The participants weren’t assigned different walking amounts. The analysis describes associations between their recorded activity and later outcomes, rather than testing a programme that added a specified number of steps.

Walking pace is more than one measurement

Only 7 cohorts provided stepping-rate measures. Before accounting for the total daily steps, faster stepping was associated with lower mortality. After adjustment, the results depended on how pace was measured.

The association remained for peak 30-minute and 60-minute stepping rates. These measures used the day’s highest-step minutes, which did not have to be consecutive. A peak 30-minute value therefore does not mean someone completed one uninterrupted 30-minute brisk walk.

For other measures, such as time spent above particular stepping-rate thresholds, the overall picture was less clear after accounting for step totals. The authors considered the evidence inconclusive about additional mortality benefits from intensity beyond total steps. Faster walkers often also accumulate more steps, making the 2 difficult to disentangle.

Extra benefit from walking faster remained unclear

Groups with the highest versus lowest values of each pace measure, after accounting for daily step totals and other factors. These are observational mortality associations.

Lower mortality with a higher pace measureNo differenceHigher mortality with a higher pace measure
  • Linked to lower mortality

  • No clear mortality association

Dot: the reported ratio. Line: the uncertainty around it. The midpoint marks the same outcome in both groups.

A higher peak rate was linked to lower mortality, but time at 100 or more steps per minute had no clear association. The pattern depended on the measure; it cannot show that walking faster caused a benefit.

See the numbers and study details
Mortality hazard ratio (logarithmic scale)
OutcomeEstimate95% confidence interval
Peak pace across the busiest 30 minutes0.670.56 … 0.83
Time walking at 100+ steps per minute0.860.58 … 1.28

1 = the same mortality hazard in the highest and lowest pace groups

Summary/Findings: model adjusted for step totals, highest versus lowest quartile; Results/Figure4; Methods individual-study analyses (model3)

Source: Paluch et al., The Lancet Public Health (2022)

Use the numbers as information, not promises

The analysis supports taking your daily movement seriously without making 10,000 a pass-or-fail test. It doesn’t establish that pace is irrelevant, or that a particular combination guarantees a longer life.

Health and lifestyle differences could influence the associations despite statistical adjustments. Steps were recorded only at baseline, and devices differed. Most participants were from high-income settings and predominantly White populations, which limits generalisation.

For your own routine, looking at patterns across several days can be more useful than judging a single total. Keep a clear distinction between the amount you walk, how a device describes pace, and what an observational health association can actually prove.

Sources

  1. Daily steps and all-cause mortality: a meta-analysis of 15 international cohorts. Paluch AE, Bajpai S, Bassett DR, et al. The Lancet Public Health. 2022;7(3):e219–e228. doi: 10.1016/S2468-2667(21)00302-9. Study.